county news online
Columbus Dispatch...
Ohio’s new farm chief can overturn denial of egg farm
Leery of trucks, Union County officials balk
By Spencer Hunt
Thursday, April 14, 2011

A state hearing officer said the Ohio Department of Agriculture should reject a proposed egg megafarm in Union County because local officials don’t support it.

The decision, released yesterday, was a setback for Hi-Q Egg Products. The Iowa-based company had objected to former Agriculture Department Director Robert Boggs’ decision to withhold a permit needed to build the farm that would contain 6 million chickens.

The ball is now in the new agriculture director’s court.

Environmental advocates said the issue poses a policy test for Director James Zehringer, who will make the agency’s final decision in the case.

Zehringer owned a large livestock farm in Mercer County before he was appointed by Gov. John Kasich to the post.

Regardless of Zehringer’s decision, advocates said yesterday that they fear the agency might soon try to get rid of a requirement in state livestock laws that Union County officials used to “veto” the proposed farm.

“There is an effort under way to change the code for the environmental livestock-permitting program to eliminate the need for a county to sign off,” said Cheryl Johncox, chairwoman of the Ohio Environmental Stewardship Alliance.

Andy Ware, an Ohio Department of Agriculture spokesman, said that during a March 16 meeting, members of the agency’s Concentrated Animal Feeding Facilities Advisory Committee voted 12-2 to pass a proposal that recommends giving local government officials a 75-day limit to file their responses to proposed large-livestock permits.

“If they haven’t done that within that 75-day period, then the permit process moves forward,” Ware said.

The committee vote doesn’t change the rules. Agriculture officials would first have to decide it’s a good idea and then ask state lawmakers and Kasich to change the law.

In August, Boggs said that the Union County commissioners’ refusal to acknowledge they had received Hi-Q’s road plan for its proposed farm meant the permit application was incomplete.

Commissioner Charles Hall said he and other officials feared truck traffic to and from the egg farm would cause excessive damage to county and township roads.

“The road issue was the main thing,” Hall said. “Hi-Q just continually stonewalled us on all issues that we had brought before them.”

Kevin Braig, a Hi-Q attorney, argued that state law requires that county officials respond to the company’s plan with their own recommendations. He said they didn’t respond, and that meant the state could approve the permits.

“Hi-Q followed the law 100percent and did absolutely everything that it was required to do,” Braig said.

Hearing officer Andrew P. Cooke’s opinion, filed yesterday morning, said the permit is incomplete without the local officials’ approval. Cooke declined to discuss his decision.

Hi-Q has two weeks to decide if it will file a written objection to Cooke’s opinion. Bill Schwaderer, an Ohio Department of Agriculture spokesman, said the agency and Zehringer can’t discuss the case until a decision is made.

Environmental groups oppose the farm because they fear chicken manure would foul nearby Bokes Creek. The stream already is polluted by runoff from other nearby poultry operations, according to a 2002 Ohio Environmental Protection Agency stream assessment.

Joe Logan, agricultural-program director with the Ohio Environmental Council, said the hearing officer’s decision shows that local officials can and should have a say in proposed farms. Logan is also a member of the advisory committee and voted against the proposed 75-day limit, saying it would weaken local officials’ “leverage.”

“We are certainly gratified that the hearing officer expressed some appreciation and some deference for local authority in this matter,” Logan said.

Read it at the Columbus Dispatch

 
senior scribes

County News Online

is a Fundraiser for the Senior Scribes Scholarship Committee. All net profits go into a fund for Darke County Senior Scholarships
contact
Copyright © 2011 and design by cigs.kometweb.com