county news online
text
Is it Time for McGuffey to Return to the Public Classroom?
By Steve Gruber, Ph.D., Chair, Education Department
Cedarville University

During much of the 19th and early 20th centuries the textbooks of William H. McGuffey provided young students with their introduction to the joy of reading. McGuffey discovered that he could improve reading skills in his students by making reading more fun. The McGuffey Readers were comprised of poems, essays, speeches, and short stories which emphasized a positive outlook on life. During the 19th century the Readers were one of the most read books with over 120 million copies being sold.

Beyond their value in teaching reading skills the Readers inculcated into the minds of young readers values such as honesty, truthfulness, obedience, kindness, thrift, industry, patriotism, and piety. Many of the essays and short stories referenced quotations from the Bible and classic scholars. Unfortunately today, much of what was contained in McGuffey’s Readers would be considered politically incorrect or in direct violation of the doctrine of “separation of church and state”. Therefore, educators in public schools would not be encouraged to use the Readers as part of their classroom curriculum.

Has our aversion to all things religious placed public education in a moral vacuum? Can there truly be a character education curriculum without moral authority?

Certainly the classroom of the 21st century is vastly different from those of the 19th. No one would suggest that we abandon the current classroom technology in order to return to kerosene lamps, chalkboards, and wood stoves. Teaching skills that are relevant to the world in which students live is just as important today as yesterday. However, I would challenge the teachers of today to pick up a copy of McGuffey’s Fifth Reader and see for themselves the erosion in reading and vocabulary skills. Most adults of today would struggle with the reading selections once read by elementary students of the 19th century.

In addition to discovering the erosion of reading skills, today’s adults would also be confronted with the societal slide in civility, ethics, and morality that is now impacting many of our public schools.

Perhaps it is time to once again invite McGuffey back into our public school classrooms.  The following is an excerpt from McGuffey’s Fifth Reader pages 284-286 and was written by William Ellery Channing.

“Religion is a social concern; for it operates powerfully on society, contributing in various ways to its stability and prosperity. Religion is not merely a private affair; the community is deeply interested in its diffusion; for it is the best support of the virtues and principles, on which the social order rests.  Pure and undefiled religion is to do good; and it follows, very plainly, that if God be the Author and Friend of society, then, the recognition of him must enforce all social duty, and enlightened Piety must give its whole strength to public order.

“Few men suspect, perhaps not man comprehends, the extent of the support given by religion to every virtue. No man, perhaps, is aware how much our moral and social sentiments are fed from this fountain; how powerless conscience would become without the belief of a God; how palsied would be human benevolence, were there not the sense of a higher benevolence to quicken and sustain it; how suddenly the whole of social fabric would quake, and with what a fearful crash it would sink into hopeless ruin, were the ideas of a Supreme Being, of accountableness and of a future life to be utterly erased from every mind.

“Erase all thought and fear of God from a community, and selfishness and sensuality would absorb the whole man. Appetite, knowing no restraint, and suffering, having no solace or hope, would trample in scorn on the restraints of human laws. Virtue, duty, principle, would be mocked and spurned as unmeaning sounds. A sordid self-interest would supplant every feeling; and man would become, in fact, what the theory in atheism declares him to be, - - a companion for brutes.”

Both in content and academic rigor it is clear from this 5th reader passage that we have come a long way since the days of McGuffey---forward or backward, you decide?

Dr. Gruber is a graduate of, and teacher and principal at, Greenville High School.


 
senior scribes

County News Online

is a Fundraiser for the Senior Scribes Scholarship Committee. All net profits go into a fund for Darke County Senior Scholarships
contact
Copyright © 2011 and design by cigs.kometweb.com